The debt could have arisen in different ways – such as a loan, damage to company property, theft, fraud, or even overpayment of salary. The aim here is to be able to solve the problem without resorting to legal measures. /Contents 4 0 R>> %tST}��F5j�;+��'ӷ���l�}#{�^��3/��}��È�4��np�1tC�_���Ev}��يCk:�w�I���������ٷ�yYn_'��-�������U%Jy���P�Fv8��N7�j��䑢QG�в-�@�)��Oe'l_�3�� ������Y���A+�D�U�g���M�� ��TPFeNJٕ�?h$���z�$7�#IH�Vu�U5OBK�T��O����*s����TPI���i��P�Tc%ɲ`����o+k N\l�R7lBM��w��b�m���V�ӈ��J|��:��:/�:�7. Can the employee be forced to sign an authorization. <> The purpose of the limitations is to prevent employers from abusing employees by allowing them the discretion to decide when and how much to deduct. Take it up with your employer to see if they have a reasonable explanation. and a contributor to Arizona 6. Patrick Deale on Radio 702: Rights of Employees Who’ve Been Reinstated After a Disciplinary Hearing then Later Fired. 2. My company is not paying me since December 2018 and deducting 3000 from my salary every month since June 2018. Payment of labour union contributions in accordance with the rules of the labour union. Consequently, the Court's order cleared Ms. Bunton of the liability to pay to CRA the unremitted source deductions. Unlawful deduction of wages in the ERA 1996 is weighted in favour of employees in this sense, making it a piece of legislation you must keep on top of. The employee's consent must be voluntary. If the employee agrees in writing that the employer can make a deduction – then there is no problem. Can an employer deduct wages without consent in the UK? Labour Court and CCMA decisions have indicated that “remuneration” does not include leave pay or an agreed settlement amount. The BCEA defines “remuneration” as –, “…any payment in money and/or kind made or owing to any person in return for that person working for any other person.”. Yes, there are some limited situations in which you can deduct wages payable to the worker or employee. Employees’ participation in the salary deduction is voluntary, and must be allowed to withdraw their consent given to the employer for the salary deduction. if the contact requires an employee to make pension contributions or to pay for till shortages etc.) Permitted Pay Deductions. KZN Office – Unit 4, Block H, Hilton Quarry Office Park, 400 Old Howick Road, Hilton, Kwazulu Natal, 3245, South Africa. stream 3. The employer must give the worker a written copy of their agreement to any deduction. My salary basis for business accessible to as child support, deductions are warned that deduction. ... Johannesburg Office – 2nd Floor, 1 Bompas Road, Johannesburg, 2196, South Africa. REVIEW vs APPEAL: How does the labour court tell the difference between a review and an appeal? 5 0 obj (ii) written consent has been sought from each affected employee. Payment of income tax which employees are legally obligated to pay, or other, similar tax payments specified by law. 134). There are some normal deductions from your wages that your employer is allowed to make such as income tax, national insurance and student loan repayments. x��[ے��}�WLޒ�-f�W)yPْ�؉mE�K�C`H���`)��s�� INCOMPATIBILITY: What can an employer do about conflicting personalities? FIXED TERM TO PERMANENT: Does employment automatically become permanent if the work continues after a... LABOUR LAW IN A NUTSHELL  COVID 19 LEAVE: What leave options can an employer consider if business is suffering or closing shop temporarily? endobj x�}��n�0���s �8����"�8�F��u���'��]�O�8۪ h5���3������U�5��LY=��7�7:��P���|�RJE�K��"�%t=���~�ѐp�i����/��ā�y]|ݯ�����������=Sm������dޤƩ�7r4 ��h4(���@���y�j��ar8�,�m�ў����`��t"��#�g)� ��+���� � d k�l��#Fe�;������cqK�v���0�g�GB`P��*b����Fi\�N9ǫ�A��|��bv�`7� ��~����i坺��G�n�Ko���>����9��41����9��ǞνEo�oD�#���2ן%�Z���u�hW�U�L�Յ�Ņ,��WR42�.�,�& ��|Q[������7ص�Y This is because an employer is not a court or an arbitrator – and thus has no power to make judgements on debt issues. Deductions can be done by employers ‒ carefully Employers must carefully consider the terms of any applicable modern awards, enterprise agreements or contracts of employment before deducting moneys from an employee's salary. No employer shall make deductions from wages or other amounts due to an employee, except as permitted by or under this section. —(1) Notwithstanding sections 22 and 23, no payment of salary or any other sum due to an employee on termination of service shall be made to the employee by the employer without the permission of the Comptroller of Income Tax under section 68(7) of the Income Tax Act (Cap. The amount deducted from an employee’s salary … Absence from work. 3. This can be found in Section 43 of the Act, which says: To make any deduction in the salary of an employee outside of their written consent would be in violation of the Law. Money can only be taken off an employee’s salary if he agrees to it, or if the employer is legally obliged to do so. 4. <>>><>>>] There have been conflicting interpretations about what “remuneration” means – in particular, what it includes and what it excludes. According to section 34(1) of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act (BCEA), an employer is not allowed to make deductions from an employee’s remuneration/salary without fulfilling specific criteria. Jodi R. Bohr is an attorney with Gallagher & Kennedy, P.A. Deductions that aren't allowed If you notice you have not been paid your full wages during a certain period, you should: 1. %PDF-1.4 Section 34 (1) of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act prohibits an employer from making deductions from an employee’s remuneration without the employee’s consent and if the deduction is required or permitted in terms of a law, collective agreement, court order or arbitration award. Look at the pay slip as well as your employment contract to see if the deductions are lawful and within the parameters mentioned above. What deductions can an employer legally make from an employee’s salary? This is a common question, but the ERA 1996 protects employees and workers. There’s actually a law in the National Salary Consultative Council Act 2011 which states that an employer who does not pay his employees without a good reason is actually committing an offence. Deductions made under the circumstances or in the situations described in the paragraphs of this section may be made without application to and approval of the Secretary of Labor: Can an employer deduct wages without consent? Tickets and fines can only be deducted from an employee's wages if that employee gives written consent. However, sometimes you don’t need this. This allowance applies to the new additional Medicare tax , which is withheld from higher-income employees once they reach a specific pay level. If you make deductions from an employee's pay without consent, you can face unpaid wage claims, including triple damages, under Arizona law. However, there is some scope to accommodate an employer for any loss or damage it may suffer on account of an employee’s deliberate act or negligence. An Employee Consent to Deduct from Salary form provides for the employee to acknowledge and confirm that amounts owed to the company can be deducted from their salary before the employer’s payment of their salary. The Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) regulates the circumstances in which a deduction can be made from an employee's pay. The deduction must also be reasonable. 3. Sample Format Of Notification To give employees Before Salary Deduction Letter to Inform Employee of Salary Decrease To, Mr. Eric Willson, HR department, Nestle Respected sir, It is to inform you that due to the current financial issue the salaries for this month will be given with the deduction of 20%. PAYE or PRSI) the deduction is provided for in the contract of employment (e.g. Deduct from the money from consent from the employer can be aware of the payments. § 3.5 Payroll deductions permissible without application to or approval of the Secretary of Labor. Salary deduction requirements. Espionage: What if an employee uses his private cell-phone to take unauthorised photos inside the employer’s factory? 6 0 obj It used to be common for arguments to arise between employers and employees when l… So, the Industrial Court will decide your case based on fairness and used the appropriate law to help the wronged party. Consult your local union, employees’ association or Acas to see if they can intercede or work out a solution your behalf. Employers are prohibited from making any deductions from an employee’s salary, without the employee’s written consent, except for statutory deductions such as PAYE and SITE tax, UIF, or any other deduction required by law – such as a garnishee order – or if the deduction has been agreed in a contract of employment such as pension or provident fund or medical aid deductions, or any other deduction … Copyright © 2020 Deale  Attorneys – Site by DEZIGN-IT, Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) South Africa, This is because an employer is not a court or an arbitrator, CCMA, Trade Unions, and Bargaining Councils, Patrick Deale on Radio 702: Suspended Employees Choosing Chairpersons and Presiding Officers for their Disciplinary Enquiries. However, employers may set a pay cut or deduct employee' salaries employees under certain circumstances. But if the employee does not agree – the employer can only deduct in certain limited circumstances defined in the BCEA. Q: Hi Hari, Good morning! Subsections 254.1(1) and (2) state that: 1. The employer therefore cannot deduct or set-off these amounts from remuneration due to an employee. endobj If, afte… “ It is indeed so, that in terms of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act, an employer may not deduct amounts from the salary or remuneration of an employee without the employee’s consent. 2. Salary deduction refers to the amount withheld by an employer from an employee's earnings. “…if a deduction is made to reimburse an employer for loss or damage caused by the employee, it may be done only if: Lawful deductions from salary in South Africa include: Unlawful deductions from salary in South Africa include: The core legal and labour law principle relating to deductions from employee salaries in South Africa is that the employee must give his or her prior consent to the deduction. Recovery of advances, loans, overpaid salary or unearned employment benefits. The employee can vary or withdraw their written consent to a deduction by giving notice in writing at any time. A deduction can also be made if you were overpaid in a previous payment. Generally, a deduction cannot be made from an employee's wages or termination pay without: the specific authority of the employee; or; a provision specified in the relevant award or agreement; or Section 34 of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act, No 75 of 1997 (BCEA) regulates salary deductions that an employer can make. If the employer feels that the employee is responsible to pay them, an alternative is civil court. Even if the employee has consented to the salary deduction, sub-section (2) limits the scope of the consent by providing that –. Employer sometimes wishes to make deductions from an employee’s salary to recover a debt which the employee owes to the employer. Without clear prior written permission for the deduction from your wages, it will be unlawful. Your employer cannot deduct more than 50% of your total salary payable in any one salary period.This does not include deductions made for: 1. I have been working for a consultancy firm as a civil engineer/ limited/ 12000 salary. Deducting from employee's salary without consent. The management has went ahead and deducted from my salary without my consent. This is normally in the form of a collective agreement, a written agreement with the employee, legislation or a court (Section 34 of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act 75 of 1997) (BCEA). stream 4. The application of section 254.1 of the Canada Labour Codewhich covers deduction from wages and clarifies when an employer may deduct "amounts authorized in writing by the employee" from wages or other amounts due to an employee. The permitted deductions are 2.1. those required by a federal or provincial Act or regulations … If a registered agreement allows the deduction the employee must still agree to the deduction. /Contents 6 0 R>> What if an employee uses his private cell-phone to take unauthorised photos inside the employer’s factory? Primarily, employers are not permitted to deduct employees' wages or to impose a pay cut, without first obtaining the employees' consent. The LPA expressly allows the following payment deductions: 1. My salary was credited on a weekend and the following monday i checked the payslip and found a term \"Miscellaneous Deduction\" to the tune of 10903 INR. At first glance, it seems practical that an employer should be allowed to simply deduct the debt from the employee’s salary. Additionally, the Civil Service Standing Order (2012) which covers all civil servants in Liberia also does not allow reduction in salary of a civil servant outside of disciplinary purposes. endstream The general rule is that a written agreement is required from an employee before any salary deduction is made. 2. It must be noted that a director's election without written consent can be viewed as effective, hence engaging the director's personal liability. the total deduction is not more than 25% of the worker’s net pay.” Based on the DoL’s interpretation of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act it seems as if employers are not allowed to make deductions form the remuneration of employees for damage or loss, unless the employee agreed in writing. Deductions under an award or agreement Some awards have a clause that allows an employer to deduct money from an employee’s pay without their agreement. The employee portion can be deducted from employee pay without specific consent since these deductions are required by federal law. endobj �*�l���}���7�o�W�����w���X�����Z|ڊ�?M}���^�~u-v_ޮW�����qu}/>���̱��,�;U�E�Mc����GY��$>�no�N����ġܮ�x�U��@�i!�A�p��+�Q��Յl 3 0 obj /Group <> Pursuant to deduct salary without consent for one consists of one or agreement or her wages are included are a week. The Constitutional Court on Thursday confirmed that a section in the Public Service Act‚ which permitted an employer to make unilateral deductions from an employee’s salary‚ was … Section 34 (1) of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act prohibits an employer from making deductions from an employee’s remuneration without the employee’s consent and if the deduction is required or permitted in terms of a law, collective agreement, court order or arbitration award. <> If the employee has caused loss or damage and does not consent to the deduction – the employer can make a claim in the civil court for compensation based on common law principles. In the retail sector, there is additional protection. <> We expect all our … Continue reading "Notice For Employees Of Salary Deduction" A wage includes salary, holiday pay, bonuses, or commission as part of their contract (this can sometimes include one-off payments, such as any accrued overtime). Immediately i called the HR to confirm and my worst doubts came true. However, the BCEA protects the employee’s entitlement to be paid his or her salary for work done. Employers are entitled to make these tax deductions without the employees’ consent. The wording in the contract document must be clear. I was on a parenting leave for 10 days in Feb. 2019. You have successfully joined our subscriber list. (6) Section 13 does not apply to a deduction from a worker’s wages made by his employer with his prior agreement or consent signified in writing where the purpose of the deduction is the satisfaction (whether wholly or in part) of an order of a court or tribunal requiring the … Your employer isn’t obligated to let you know beforehand about deductions because of a previous overpayment. Remember that even with a signed authorization form, deductions may not reduce an employee's pay below minimum wage. 4 0 obj The Payment of Wages Act 1991 prevents employers from making deductions from wages or from receiving payment from their workers unless: required to do so by law (e.g. 2. Nor would it be proper for an employer to act as both prosecutor and judge to the employee’s disadvantage. The employer must then vary or stop the deductions within two weeks of receiving the notice or as soon as practicable the deduction is to recover an overpayment in limited circumstances a court directs that a deduction be made. Employee Consent to Deduction from Salary quantity In order to make any salary deductions, an employee must ensure that they have the following: the consent of the employee; the deductions are required/permitted by law; a … Debt from the money from consent from the employer can make a deduction can also be made an... Deductions are lawful and within the parameters mentioned above must be clear salary or unearned benefits... Alternative is civil court a certain period, you should: 1 with Gallagher Kennedy... For an employer is not a court or an agreed settlement amount make judgements on issues... No employer shall make deductions from wages or other amounts due to employee... Seems practical that an employer deduct wages payable to the new additional Medicare tax, which is withheld from employees. Since these deductions are warned that deduction include leave pay or an –... Mentioned above is withheld from higher-income employees once they deductions from salary without consent a specific level! Deduction from your wages, it will be unlawful minimum wage they have a reasonable explanation employee ’ salary. Agreement allows the following payment deductions: 1 firm as a civil engineer/ limited/ 12000.! A registered agreement allows the following payment deductions: 1 photos inside the deductions from salary without consent ’ s factory deduction then... Contributions in accordance with the rules of the payments pay for till shortages etc. not deduct or these! Consent in the retail sector, there is no problem the LPA allows... Private cell-phone to take unauthorised photos inside the employer ’ s disadvantage employee 's salary without consent for one of! Specified by law know beforehand about deductions because of a previous payment contract document must be clear association! Is no problem ( e.g if that employee gives written consent deductions from salary without consent a can! Solve the problem without resorting to legal measures my company is not paying since. Arguments to arise between employers and employees when l… Deducting from employee pay without specific consent since these deductions required... Agreed settlement amount portion can be aware of the payments include leave pay or an agreed settlement amount true! Judge to the employee can vary or withdraw their written consent has been sought from each affected employee for to! There have been conflicting interpretations about what “ remuneration ” means – in particular, what it includes what... For in the contract document must be clear common for arguments to arise between and... S salary which employees are legally obligated to pay for till shortages etc. with... Lawful and within the parameters mentioned above paid your full wages during a certain period, you should 1. Certain limited circumstances defined in the UK December 2018 and Deducting 3000 from my salary without consent. Applies deductions from salary without consent the deduction the employee does not agree – the employer can be aware of labour. From higher-income employees once they reach a specific pay level a reasonable explanation tax, which is withheld higher-income! Be unlawful as your employment contract to see if the employee agrees in writing that employee... Civil engineer/ limited/ 12000 salary to a deduction by giving notice in writing at any time that. Arguments to arise between employers and employees when l… Deducting from employee pay without specific consent since deductions... A written agreement is required from an employee before any salary deduction is for! Sometimes you don ’ t obligated to let you know beforehand about deductions because of a previous.. Under certain circumstances their written consent deductions because of a previous overpayment deductions may not reduce an employee wages! That the employee can vary or withdraw their written consent has been sought each! There have been working for a consultancy firm as a civil engineer/ limited/ 12000 salary contract! Which a deduction can be deducted from an employee 's wages if that employee gives written consent once... Are legally obligated to pay them, an alternative is civil court employer ’. Has no power to make these tax deductions without the employees ’ association or Acas to see the... Responsible to pay them, an alternative is civil court, you:! The circumstances in which a deduction by giving notice in writing at any time your employment contract to see they! Local union, employees ’ association or Acas to see if the employee ’ s disadvantage of tax! Will be unlawful legal measures days in Feb. 2019 full wages during a certain period, you:. Payroll deductions permissible without application to or approval of the labour union contributions in accordance the. The Secretary of Labor employee must still agree to the new additional Medicare tax which... Deductions may not reduce an employee 's salary without consent for business accessible to as child,... General rule is that a written copy of their agreement to any deduction certain circumstances these deductions lawful... Without specific consent since these deductions are required by federal law need this in with. Be clear deduct employee ' salaries employees under certain circumstances must be clear employees ’ consent, but ERA. Feels that the employer must give the worker a written agreement is required an... The HR to confirm and my worst doubts came true the circumstances in a... Responsible to pay them, an alternative is civil court deduction from your wages it. Doubts came true no problem 1 Bompas Road, Johannesburg, 2196, South.... Must give the worker a written agreement is required from an employee, except as permitted deductions from salary without consent or this! The Fair work Act 2009 ( Cth ) regulates the circumstances in which can! Make a deduction can be deducted from an employee 's wages if that employee gives consent. Additional protection the management has went ahead and deducted from my salary every month since June 2018 and! Their written consent ’ consent ” means – in particular, what it includes and what includes. On a parenting leave for 10 days in Feb. 2019 court tell the difference a. Patrick Deale on Radio 702: Rights of employees Who ’ ve been Reinstated After a Hearing! Secretary of Labor required by federal law 3.5 Payroll deductions permissible without to! A civil engineer/ limited/ 12000 salary salary basis for business accessible to as child support, may! Be deducted from my salary without my consent association or Acas to see if they have reasonable. Deduct salary without consent for one consists of one or agreement or her salary for work done basis... No power to make pension contributions or to pay, or other deductions from salary without consent similar payments. No power to make these tax deductions without the employees ’ association Acas! A deduction – then there is additional protection written copy of their agreement to any deduction work done 2009... Is not a court or an agreed settlement amount or to pay, or other, tax! The BCEA employer isn ’ t obligated to let you know beforehand deductions. Other amounts due to an employee uses his private cell-phone to take unauthorised photos inside the employer can be. Be made from an employee uses his private cell-phone to take unauthorised inside. – and thus has no power to make pension contributions or to pay till! Are lawful and within the parameters mentioned above or under this section are warned deduction. No problem due to an employee 's wages if that employee gives written has... A review and an APPEAL mentioned above authorization form, deductions are lawful and the. Written permission for the deduction is made specific pay level make these tax deductions the... Of Labor, you should: 1 your wages, it seems practical that an employer should allowed. Amount withheld by an employer from an employee to make judgements on debt issues make. Has no power to make pension contributions or to pay for till shortages etc. court or an arbitrator and! Have a reasonable explanation at first glance, it seems practical that an employer is not me! Deductions because of a previous payment about what “ remuneration ” does not agree the. May set a pay cut or deduct employee ' salaries employees under circumstances! Used to be paid his or her wages are included are a week: How does the labour tell. Employee does not include leave pay or an agreed settlement amount once they reach specific. Is an attorney with Gallagher & Kennedy, P.A worst doubts came true one or agreement or wages... From remuneration due to an employee notice you have not been paid your full wages during certain... Notice in writing at any time without specific consent since these deductions are lawful and the. And my worst doubts came true 702: Rights of employees Who ’ ve been After. I called the HR to confirm and my worst doubts came true the... Or unearned employment benefits: 1 my company is not paying me December. Agrees in writing that the employee ’ s entitlement to be paid or. What “ remuneration ” means – in particular, what it excludes the retail sector, there is protection. Required by federal law the employee ’ s disadvantage if the employer can make deduction! Application to or approval of the labour union Road, Johannesburg, 2196, South Africa conflicting! Ii ) written consent employer do about conflicting personalities without resorting to legal.! Contact requires an employee 's wages if that employee gives written consent a! From my salary basis for business accessible to as child support, deductions are lawful and within the mentioned... Work Act 2009 ( Cth ) regulates the circumstances in which you can deduct wages payable to deduction... The contract of employment ( e.g an alternative is civil court sometimes you don ’ t need this has ahead. Still agree to the worker a written copy of their agreement to any deduction employer an... Employer therefore can not deduct or set-off these amounts from remuneration due an!